Shamrock Showdown PPV Grading and Notes

[Jana Rikar]

Scoring from Shamrock Showdown



Voting was done by myself. A Second Judge outside of the fed looked at each of the Four Qualifying Matches and gave their impression of the winners, with no scoring involved. All Four matches were in agreement between myself and the Judge. I can give more candid remarks to each handler. Feel free to ask privately via DM or via Twitter.

Voting was done on Wednesday after Deadline and was done in the order received.

Drake and Ursula contacted me between Deadline and Showtime about missing the Deadline. That's why they were written out and not given a no-show loss. I can give a grade for Chris if he wants it, but I didn't do one with no opponent available.

The Legends Match was using two characters from the previous version of the DWF as was strictly for entertainment purposes. You may use the info from the match in the future.

I'll try to make this a regular grading post after every show to help with improvements for your character and for the portrayal of the characters as we venture on in the DWF

Thanks again for all the help.
Jana

[/]QUALIFYING MATCHES[/]
Winner of each match advances to the Main Event

'Alpha Bitch' Aidan Carlisle vs. Coral Rose

Aidan - 75
Character - 24
Story - 28
Entertainment - 23

Aidan had Very Good Shoot and set up the Character well, but it didn't have a ton of pop or wow factor for the Entertainment portion

Coral - 69
Character - 22
Story - 26
Entertainment - 21

Coral had Very Good Shoot. The Character and the Entertainment were there but again, no pop


Nora Harris vs. Heidi Thompson

Nora - 67
Character - 26
Story - 20
Entertainment - 21

Nora has Tons of Character, but felt soft on the shoot. Entertainment was fair as well

Heidi - 68
Character - 24
Story - 24
Entertainment - 20

Heidi set up her Character as well as had some good shoot. I didn't get the fun off the page like I did with others


Summer vs. Trixie

Summer - 67
Character - 23
Story - 19
Entertainment - 25

Summer was very enjoyable to read, but lacked the shoot badly. The character has promise.

Trixie - 70
Character - 19
Story - 28
Entertainment - 23

Lots of good shoot here. I just don't know who Trixie is. Entertainment was fair as well.


'The Burning Heart' James Edwards vs. Faith Rivers

James - 63
Character - 20
Story - 24
Entertainment - 19

James felt flat. His shoot was solid, but it seemed very bland. Not a lot of wow factor either

Faith - 65
Character - 21
Story - 24
Entertainment - 20

Faith had a pretty good shoot and was average elsewhere.

[/]WINNER IS IN THE MAIN EVENT ON TNT- THE SHOW IN PENSACOLA[/]
-Three Way Elimination Match-
'Mad' Alice Quinn vs. Drake Parker vs. Patrick Carson

Alice - 75
Character - 28
Story - 21
Entertainment - 26

Alice has TONS of Character and was very enjoyable to read. More Focus on the opponent and she's going to be formidable.

Patrick - 69
Character - 24
Story - 24
Entertainment - 21

Solid performance from Patrick. A little more charisma and he will be a very good character to enjoy

[/]'ONE SHOT' DR. PEPPER VS. M&M'S MATCH[/]
Chris Andrew vs. Ursula Areano
(From Seattle Pro & DARC) (from GZWA, BWF, & NGIW)

[/]LEGENDS MATCH[/]
Big Daddy Mad Dog vs. 'The Madness' Tyler Borden w/ the 'Dark Angel' Alexandra Darkin

[/]MAIN EVENT[/]
Savannah River Street Fight For the Defiant Championship
-Winner Throws One of Their Opponents into the Savannah River-
Aidan Carlisle vs. Heidi Thompson vs. Trixie vs. Faith Rivers

Aidan - 75
Heidi - 68
Trixie - 70
Faith - 65

Aidan had the highest scoring of the 4 remaining and picked up the win. Faith had the lowest and was dumped in the river.